What is Thermal Work Limit (TWL)?

Thermal Work Limit (TWL) is an integrated measure of the dry bulb temperature, wet bulb temperature, wind speed and radiant heat. The TWL predicts the maximum level of work that can be carried out in a given environment, without workers exceeding a safe core body temperature (38.2 C or 100.8 F) and sweat rate (< 1.2 kg or 2.6 lb per hour).  The TWL is developed from published studies of human heat transfer and moisture equations through clothing. In excessively hot conditions, the index can determine the safe work duration, thus preventing heat-related illness and providing guidelines for work/rest cycling. The TWL guidelines have been implemented in Abu Dhabi Emirate, UAE and Australian mines and have produced a substantial decrease in the number of heat related illness cases.


Application of TWL

The TWL heat stress index is the heat stress index that has been included in the Abu Dhabi EHSMS code of practice for the management of Heat Stress. TWL gives a measure of the maximum safe work rate for the environmental conditions present at a worksite. If TWL is too low then even low rates of work cannot safely be carried out continuously and extra rest breaks and other precautions are needed to ensure worker safety.

Why TWL is better than WBGT and other indices?

The Wet Bulb Globe Temperature (WBGT) has been widely used and still the standard in many industries. The WBGT is relatively easy to measure and the instrumentation is not overly expensive, however it has several shortcomings as a measure of thermal stress. WBGT does not incorporate direct measure of wind speed and requires estimation of metabolic rates, which can have a margin of error up to 50%. The guidelines are also unrealistic, as stringent application of the protocol would shutdown every construction site in Middle East during summer.


Heat stress indexes such as WBGT and ISO 7933 do not take into account the effects of long hours of hard work, dehydration, or the impact of personal protective clothing and equipment. The studies in UAE and other regions of the world have shown that WBGT is too conservative and inappropriate for practical in industry. Other problems exist with rational indices such as ISO 7933, especially when applied to hot, humid environment with low wind speeds, including the incorrect adjustment of wind speed, absence of a fluid replacement term and incorrect assumption of the clothing insulation.


History of TWL

The idea of a thermal work limit (TWL) was developed by Dr. Graham Bates and Dr. Derrick Brake in 1997. Over the past 80 years, many heat stress indices have been developed to assist with the management of heat stress problems. Some of these have been developed for particular industries and empirically derived such as ISO 7933 and WBGT. These indices required estimation of metabolic rate but failed to consider the direct measurement of wind speed, reduction of work rate, location and time shift during work and removal of clothing, making these indices not accurate for self-paced and acclimatized workers. The need for a heat stress index designed primarily for self-paced workers has led to the development of the thermal work limit (TWL).


TWL and its accompanying management protocols have been introduced into several industrial operations where workers are subject to thermal stress. Approximately 1400 persons work in these locations with over 10 million man-shifts being worked between 1965 and 1995 at wet bulb temperatures in excess of 28 °C (82 °F). Since the introduction of TWL-based policies in the Australian mining industry, the amount of man-hours lost due to serious heat illness has fallen from 12 million to 6 million, and the amount lost due to all heat illness incidences has fallen from 31 million to 18 million.


Theory

The basic purpose of the thermal work limit index is to calculate the maximum metabolic rate, in watts of metabolic heat per square meter of body surface area, that can be continuously expended in a particular thermal environment, in order to keep the body within safe physiological limits. The TWL is an integrated measure of the dry bulb, wet bulb, wind speed and radiant heat. From these variables, and taking into consideration the type of clothing worn and acclimatization state of the worker, the TWL predicts the maximum level of work that can be carried out in a given environment, without workers exceeding a safe core body temperature 38.2 °C (100.8 °F) and sweat rate.


In excessively hot conditions, the index can also determine the safe work duration, thus providing guidelines for work/rest cycling. Sweat rates are also calculated, so the level of fluid replacement necessary to avoid dehydration can be established. The thermal work limit algorithm builds on work originated by Mitchell and Whillier, who developed an index “specific cooling power,” which subsequently became known as “air cooling power” (ACP).

Want to know more about how to measure TWL? Click here

Reference

  • Brake, D. J.; Bates, G. P. (2002). "Limiting Metabolic Rate (Thermal Work Limit) as an Index of Thermal Stress". Applied Occupational and Environmental Hygiene17 (3): 176–186
  • Thermal Work Limit Wikipedia
  • Miller, V. S.; Bates, G. P. (2007). "The Thermal Work Limit is a Simple Reliable Heat Index for the Protection of Workers in Thermally Stressful Environments". Annals of Occupational Hygiene 51 (6): 553–561